Antica Pesa Brooklyn

They were able to accommodate us last minute and from the time you arrive to when you walk out the door the experience and food on point. They quality coming out of the kitchen is top notch and the knowledge of the rest of the staff excellent from the dishes, ingredients, drinks and wine they don’t miss a beat when you ask a question. Some of the food pics were taken after we started eating the plates come out like art on a plate.

Was in New York for a weekend away and discovered this place and all its Roman glory. We booked a table for 2, myself and my Italian boyfriend. He’s super picky with Italian restaurants as he lives in Tuscany. This was as authentic as it gets. From atmosphere to the menu and exciting wine list. We stayed after for their jazz night. Loved it. All the excitement in one cozy stop. I wish I was in Brooklyn more often as I would love to make this our regular Thursday night dining destination.

Absolutely incredible experience - our group of 6 unanimously agrees this was the best restaurant experience we have ever had. Beautiful evening ambience, warm and approachable, yet elevated and refined. First on the food: it was a whole new dimension of Italian food. Familiar dishes but with a new depth of flavor I had not experienced before. The restaurant’s roots are in Rome, which means they have a unique take on certain dishes.. there’s an emphasis on a very specific level of al dente pasta, a more intensely rich type of cacio e pepe, and pork sourced from Italy served as Guanciale (crispy bits served on top of your pasta). The buffalo mozzarella crudo was delicious and delicate. The duck prosciutto had a pleasantly smokiness at the end of each bite, and the octopus was very tender and flavorful! We were very well taken care of by our wonderful server Ricardo as well as Lorenzo, the owner himself! He suggested the best thing: they offered a Bitico (spelling?) which isn’t on the menu, but is like a split pasta dish where all of us could try two of their specialties on a single plate. Both the cacio e pepe and rigatoni were other worldly. Overall I would highly recommend! We had such a wonderful time, such a warm welcome and lovely evening, along with an incredible dining experience! We’ll be back!

The dinner was a culinary explosion! . The food was fresh, authentic, and delicious. The decor was beautiful and added to the overall ambiance. The service was stellar, and the staff was attentive and knowledgeable. Lorenzo made me feel right at home. I highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to dining here again in the future!

Antica Pesa is one of my favorite places to frequent in Williamsburg. The food is amazing, service is top tier and I love the cozy vibe they have in there. Riccardo, their bar manager, is the most hospitable and always provides the best experience for me and my friends. Couldn't recommend this place more. Saluti!

Phenomenal dining experience. Food was great. Highly recommend their espresso martini, seafood risotto and pigs stomach. Even the bread in the start was delicious! The servers were so friendly and really took care of us. Lorenzo the manager was super accommodating because we were celebrating an engagement. We even forgot a hat at the table when we left then saw Lorenzo chasing after us with the hat when we realized. 10/10 experience. Will definitely be returning and highly recommend.

This restaurant was recommended, by an Italian from Rome. I can say the dishes I had were as authentic as they could have. My last Italy trip was spent in Rome, Sardinia and Polignano a Mare, and I can say this restaurant hit different areas when it came to having a Roman pasta, or one more of the coast side. My friend and I had the cacio e pepe and the anchovies pasta. Delish. Server Massimilliano was very nice and attentive. The atmosphere is romantic. Perfect for date night.

An absolute gem in every sense. The service was nothing short of exceptional—imbued with a rare, old-school charm that was both warm and delightfully witty, easily surpassing that of any five-star establishment. The ambiance, marked by a stately leather sofa, a glowing fireplace, and an inviting open kitchen, struck a perfect balance between elegance and comfort. From the moment I arrived, I felt genuinely welcomed—at once a guest and at home. My sincerest thanks for such a memorable experience.